Circumcision classed as possible child abuse in draft CPS document

[Pea]

omg u guyz!! i dont think its fair 2 label circumcision as child abuse!!! im all 4 safe circumcision procedures & everythin but when it goes wrong ppl r like "its abuse" wut about ppl who dont no how 2 do it tho? muslim leaders wanna stronger safeties & regulation systems 4 non-medical practitioners 2, coz u can2 imagine a kid gettin cut w/o even having a second think but like, i get where rabbis n jewish ppl r coming from, circumcision is def an identity thing. we need more ed & training 4 both medical ppl & parents so they dont accidentally hurt kids or make them feel weird about it lol

 

[Armored Rocket II]

this draft doc is all about setting boundaries but also kinda stigmatizing cultural practices meanwhile some ppl r sayin it's about savin kids from harm

stats show circumcision can be done safely & with proper trainin but sometimes medical pros might mess up and that's when the CPS comes in

some ppl welcome the guidelines 'cause they want to make sure kids r protected others feel it's unfair & stigmatizes relig/cultural practices

we need more education and regulation so we can find that perfect balance between respectin cultural practises & keepin kids safe

 

[Def Jam Pirate Paint]

thinkin about this draft doc its like, we gotta be careful with words & meanings they can stick or hurt people but like what if we reframe it? instead of callin it child abuse whats about sayin it a serious safety issue yeah that way we acknowledge the potential harm without stigmatizin an important cultural practice

 

[Importan]

I cant believe its come to this . Circumcision's been around for thousands of years & its been performed without incident in most cultures. Now we're having a stir because some people think it might be considered child abuse if not done properly . Its all about balance, if someone wants to get circumcised when theyre old enough, thats their choice . But forcing it on kids or doing it recklessly is not okay . We need to focus on educating ppl & regulating it better rather than stigmatizing an ancient cultural practice .

 

[Wide-eyed Worm]

it's crazy how something that's supposed to be a sacred or cultural tradition can take a hit when it comes to safety concerns... like, yeah circumcision has its own set of risks and should definitely have proper controls in place but stigmatizing an entire culture or community just 'cause we're being extra cautious feels kinda unfair . we gotta find that balance between respecting traditions and prioritizing the well-being of our young folks .