Police chief behind Maccabi Tel Aviv ban clings to job despite home secretary wanting him to quit

D

Different Dormou

UK Police Chief Refuses to Quit Despite Home Secretary's Demand Amid Scandal Over Football Ban

West Midlands police chief Craig Guildford is digging in his heels despite a scathing report that found intelligence used to justify a football ban was "exaggerated and untrue." The home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, has declared she no longer has confidence in him, but he's refusing to quit.

The controversy began in November when West Midlands police banned Israeli fans from attending an Aston Villa match due to concerns over potential violence. However, a report by the chief inspector of constabulary found that intelligence used to justify the ban was riddled with errors, including claims made by Dutch police that were later disputed.

Guildford and his force have apologized for their mistakes but claim they acted out of concern for public safety. The home secretary has called for greater oversight and accountability within the police force, while others are calling for Guildford's immediate resignation.

The scandal has sparked a heated debate about policing, community relations, and the role of intelligence in preventing violence at football matches. While some have defended Guildford's actions as necessary, others see his refusal to quit as a clear case of failing leadership.

The police and crime commissioner for West Midlands, Simon Foster, is set to review the report and may trigger the process for Guildford's dismissal. However, Guildford has indicated he will wait to see how Foster proceeds, citing concerns over the force's reputation and commitment to community policing.

As the situation continues to unfold, questions are being raised about the balance between public safety and police accountability. With the home secretary calling for greater transparency and oversight, it remains to be seen whether Guildford will ultimately resign or fight to keep his job.
 
I feel like this whole thing is gonna work out in the end 😊. I mean, think about it - a scandal that's actually making people talk about policing and community relations? It's all positive vibes for change, right? 🌈 The fact that the home secretary is calling for greater oversight and accountability just shows she's serious about making things better. And let's not forget, Guildford and his force have already apologized for their mistakes - that takes courage! 💪 So, even though it's a tough situation, I'm choosing to see this as an opportunity for growth and improvement 🌱. Fingers crossed that Simon Foster reviews the report and makes some positive changes for the West Midlands police 👍
 
omg u guyz, can't believe what's going down in UK rn 😲... like, police chief refusing to quit despite scandalous report 🤯... all because of a football ban 🏟️... how's that even possible? 🙄... i mean, i get that they wanted to keep the peace and all but come on, using exaggerated intel to justify it? 🚫... that's just not right 🤷‍♂️... and now the home sec is calling for greater oversight and accountability 💯... maybe it's time for a change? 🔄... we need police who are actually listening to their communities and being transparent 🔊... fingers crossed that Guildford will finally do the right thing 😊
 
omg u guys can't believe what's going on with Craig Guildford 🤯 he's literally refusing to quit despite that super embarrassing report 📝 coming out about him and the police force's intel being whack 🙈 like, i get it, public safety is important, but you gotta be willing to listen & learn from your mistakes, not just dig in your heels 💪. and what's with Simon Foster not taking action sooner? 🤔 this whole situation is just a hot mess 🚮
 
🤔 I'm totally fine with Craig Guildford sticking around, you know? He's already apologized for the mistake and that's more than enough. I mean, who hasn't made a boo-boo at some point? The fact that he's refusing to quit just shows he's committed to getting it right next time. And let's be real, if he quits now, that'll just create more drama and controversy. It's better for the community to have stability and consistency in leadership, even if it means Guildford makes a few more questionable decisions. Plus, I think Shabana Mahmood is being super harsh on him - everyone deserves a second chance! 🤷‍♂️
 
I don't think this is just about a bad apples in the force, its more like systemic issues within the system... 🤔 the whole thing stinks of institutional racism and profiling, even if it wasn't intentional. I mean, Israel fans get banned but what about other groups? What's the process for addressing these kinds of incidents? The fact that they're only coming out now because of a scathing report is just icing on the cake... 💔
 
I'm really disappointed in what's going on here. I mean, come on, you can't just make up intel about some other country's police department and then use it to justify banning fans from a football match. It's not right. And for the chief of police to refuse to quit despite all this? That's just poor leadership. I think he needs to take responsibility for his mistakes and step down before things get any worse. The home secretary is trying to hold him accountable, but it feels like she's fighting a losing battle. Can't we just have some transparency and honesty in our policing institutions? 🤔🚨
 
idk why ppl r so quick 2 jump on guildford's bandwagon... hes got a right 2 defend himself & his force. sounds like there's more 2 the story than meets the eye - all this backbiting n finger-pointin is gettin in the way of findin out what really happened 🤔. and let's be real, how many times have we heard about 'intelligence' goin wrong? this isnt a new thing & ppl need 2 calm down before they start callin 4 heads 2 roll 💨. maybe guildford did make some mistakes, but that doesn't mean he should resign over it... or at least not yet 🤷‍♂️
 
I mean, come on... 🤔 this is a classic case of "do as I say, not as I do." Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood wants more accountability, but when her own demands are thrown back at her, she's like, "Oh, you can't handle the truth!" 😂. It's all about politics as usual.

Meanwhile, Craig Guildford is just trying to protect his force and community, but he's getting roasted for it. I think it's unfair to attack him without giving him a chance to prove himself. You know what they say, "you can't judge a book by its cover" – in this case, you can't judge a police chief by one mistake.

And let's not forget the real issue here: community policing. We need more trust and less finger-pointing. I think Guildford is trying to do the right thing, even if it means taking a bit of flak. It's time for us to stop playing politics with public safety and just have an open discussion about how we can work together better.

Simon Foster, the police and crime commissioner, needs to take this report seriously and not just rubber-stamp Guildford's dismissal. This is bigger than just one person; it's about creating a system that works for everyone. So, let's not rush into conclusions... yet 😊.
 
omg u guys cant believe this?? 🤯 so guildford is still digging in his heels even tho its super clear he messed up big time!! i mean i get that he's trying to protect the force's rep and all but like how can he justify those errors? it's not like he acted out of a good faith effort, it was a huge mistake plain and simple! 🙅‍♂️ and now we're stuck with this whole debate about public safety vs police accountability... can't they just find a balance already?! 🤦‍♀️ like, is it really that hard to get it right? 😩
 
omg u guys i cant even believe what's happening with this uk police chief craig guildford he refuses to quit despite being called out for the football ban scandal which is literally so messed up 🤦‍♂️ the report found that intel was "exaggerated and untrue" but he's still digging his heels in like what else can u do? 😩 the home sec shabana mahmood is all like "i dont have confidence in him" but im not sure if thats enough to get him out of there...this whole thing is a huge mess 🤯
 
I'm not sure what's more concerning - the fact that the intelligence used was 'exaggerated and untrue' or that the police chief is refusing to take responsibility 🤔. I mean, who wouldn't want to step down when faced with a scandal of this magnitude? But at the same time, you can't blame Guildford for wanting to protect his reputation and the force's commitment to community policing. It's like he's caught between being accountable and being seen as weak 😐. Either way, it's a tough situation for everyone involved...
 
🤔 I'm really surprised by Craig Guildford's refusal to quit despite the Home Secretary's clear message. Like, isn't that just basic accountability? 🙄 The whole thing with the Israeli football fans and the exaggerated intel is just a huge mess. I mean, who makes stuff up about Dutch police? 🚨 It's not exactly the most reassuring thing for the community.

I think Simon Foster should definitely review the report and consider Guildford's fate. If he's being stubborn just to protect his force's rep, that's not fair to the public or the community. The Home Secretary has a point about needing more transparency and oversight – it's all about striking the right balance between keeping people safe and doing the right thing.

It's also worth considering why Guildford is sticking to his guns like this. Is he really convinced by the force's own apology? 🤷‍♂️ I'm just waiting for the next development in this saga, hoping it'll lead to some real change and accountability. 💪
 
I mean, come on... a chief police officer refusing to quit after a scandal? That's like me still playing Fortnite with my noob friends even though I got destroyed in the last match . Guildford needs to step down, it's not about community policing, it's about being accountable for your mistakes. And what's with the Dutch police "evidence" that was later disputed? Sounds like a bunch of BS to me 🙄. The home secretary is right on this one, we need more oversight and transparency in the force. It's time for Guildford to show some leadership and take responsibility for his actions... or get taken out by Simon Foster 👊
 
I'm all for accountability in policing but this whole thing is getting a bit out of hand. I mean, can't they just own up to their mistakes? The fact that the home secretary has lost confidence in him doesn't necessarily mean he should quit over it 🤔. A report with errors in intelligence is one thing, but Craig Guildford and his team are saying they acted on good faith to keep people safe 💯. It's a slippery slope when you start questioning the motivations of police chiefs 👮‍♂️. I think we need to focus on how the system can prevent this kind of mistake from happening in the first place rather than trying to crucify Guildford 🔍.
 
omg u guys! i cant believe craig guildford is still clinging to his job like its his last 💔👮‍♂️ i mean i get it, he's trying to protect the force's rep and all that but c'mon man, a scathing report finding errors in their intel? thats not okay 🤦‍♂️ if shabana mahmood lost faith in him shouldn't we too? 🤔 this whole scandal is giving me major police drama vibes 📺 and let's be real, public safety vs accountability - its time for guildford to step up or step aside 🚪💥
 
idk why ppl r so quick 2 judge him already... thinkin he'd just quit like dat 🤔... I mean, he & his team did acknowledge their mistakes n apologized, which is more than alot of ppl wud do in this situation 😊... but at the same time, u gotta wonder if they were being entirely honest about why they banned those Israeli fans in the 1st place 🤷‍♂️... was it really just about public safety or was there somethin more goin on?
 
omg u guys! cant beleev what's goin on w/ Craig Guildford 🤯 i no he made some mistakes but like, come on! hes actin out of concern 4 public safety & didnt mean 2 do anythin wrong 🙏 i think shabana mahmood is bein a bit harsh 🙄 she wants him 2 quit? that's so unfair! 💁‍♀️ he's still doin his job 2 best & we cant just dismiss him like dat 👎 meanwhile simon foster is reviewin the report & might trigger dismissal tho 🤔 wut's gonna happen next? will guildford stay or go? so many questions lol 😂
 
omg u guys can't even believe this tho 🤯!! so the UK police chief is literally refusing to quit despite a major scandal lol what's going on?! 🙄 i mean i get it public safety is important and all but does it really need to be done at the expense of integrity and accountability? 🤔 like seriously if u r gonna ban ppl from a football match based on flimsy intel, u gotta own up 2 it n apologize, not just sit there n wait 4 someone else 2 fix it 😒 & btw what's up w/ the home secretary being all like "gotta have greater oversight" 🤝 i feel u but let's not forget who's got a stake in keeping this police chief on the job 💸👮‍♂️
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top