The Trump-Kennedy Center is another front in the battle for the soul of America | Charlotte Higgins

The Kennedy Center, once a beacon of artistic excellence and bipartisan unity, has become a battleground in the cultural wars. A year ago, it was a world-class institution, boasting a resident opera company, respected artistic teams, and a critically acclaimed production of Hamilton. However, with Donald Trump's ascension to chair, the centre underwent a drastic transformation. The executive director was ousted, and his protégé Richard Grenell took over, installing policies that have decimated attendance.

Artists and audiences alike have deserted the centre in droves, citing "net neutrality" as the primary reason for their departure. This policy, championed by Grenell, insists on funding productions solely through ticket sales, disregarding the need for grants and philanthropic support. The Washington National Opera's Francesca Zambello revealed that ticket sales had plummeted to alarming levels, prompting the company to consider relocating.

The financial toll has been severe, with the opera company facing a crisis of confidence. Zambello described the centre as "a funeral parlour," where a deathly pall hung over its halls. The cancellations continue, including the annual Martin Luther King Day concert, now relocated to another venue. The seating plans on the centre's website reflect this decline, with few events selling well.

The National Symphony Orchestra, once a stalwart of Washington's cultural scene, is left isolated in the wake of the opera's departure. Its music director Gianandrea Noseda issued a statement that seemed ambiguous, yet conveyed nothing concrete. The NSO's clouds of meaninglessness have sparked debate about politics and art, with many wondering what this meant for the future of classical music.

The Smithsonian Institution's National Portrait Gallery has also succumbed to pressure, swapping out Trump's portrait in response to his perceived discomfort with its previous label. This change reflects a broader trend of institutions buckling under Trump's demands, seeking to appease him by conforming to his vision.

As we enter the final year of Trump's second term, America is facing a battle for its soul – not just on the streets, but in its cultural organisations. Will those who fight for artistic integrity prevail, or will they succumb to pressure? The outcome remains uncertain, but one thing is clear: the future of American culture hangs precariously in the balance.
 
I'm telling ya 🤔, this whole thing with the Kennedy Center is just a mess. I mean, come on, "net neutrality" as the reason for the decline? That's just it – there's no connection between ticket sales and artistic integrity. The real issue here is that Trump's people are more interested in pushing their own agenda than supporting the arts. It's not about funding through grants or philanthropy; it's about control and power.

And what's with the National Symphony Orchestra's vague statement? 🤷‍♂️ Is Gianandrea Noseda afraid to speak up or is he just playing it safe? The fact that they're isolated now speaks volumes. This isn't just about classical music; it's about the value we place on artistic expression and critical thinking.

The Smithsonian Institution's decision to swap out Trump's portrait might seem like a small thing, but it's actually a symptom of a larger problem – institutions being too afraid to take a stand. It's time for people to speak up and demand better from our cultural organisations. The future of American culture is at stake, and we need to take action before it's too late 🔥💡
 
I'm getting really worried about the state of arts and culture in America right now 🤕💔. It's like everyone's more focused on appeasing Trump than preserving our cultural heritage. I mean, what's the point of having world-class institutions like the Kennedy Center if they're just going to be used as pawns in a power struggle? 🤷‍♀️ The fact that ticket sales have plummeted and the opera company is even considering relocating is just heartbreaking 🎭😢.

And it's not just the arts – I've seen so many institutions bowing down to Trump's demands, like the Smithsonian Institution switching out his portrait. It's like they're all afraid to speak truth to power or stand up for what matters most: creativity and freedom of expression 💫🎨. As a wellness enthusiast, I believe that art has the power to heal and uplift us, but it seems like no one's fighting hard enough to protect it 🌈💪.

I think we need to take a step back and remind ourselves why these institutions exist in the first place: to bring people together, to spark imagination, and to inspire positive change 🔥💡. We can't let politics get in the way of that 💔.
 
I'm all for free market principles and all that 🤷‍♂️, but come on... a whole year ago, the Kennedy Center was on point 🎉, and now it's basically dead 🕵️‍♀️. The idea of funding productions solely through ticket sales is a bit too radical for me 🤑. I mean, what about the value of public support? Grants and philanthropy have always been essential to the arts 🌿.

The fact that artists are leaving in droves because of "net neutrality" just doesn't add up 🤔. And those cancellations... it's like a death knell for Washington's cultural scene 🔊. I'm all for a little controversy, but this is getting out of hand 😬. The National Symphony Orchestra and the Smithsonian Institution seem to be caught in the middle 🎶.

I just wish they'd find a way to balance artistic integrity with fiscal responsibility 💸. Can't we just agree on that? 🤗
 
I'm worried about what's happening at the Kennedy Center 🤔. They're losing so many great events and artists are leaving... I get that some people don't like the direction they're heading, but can't we all just agree to disagree? 🙅‍♀️ Maybe instead of fighting each other, we could try to find common ground? The arts have always been a way for us to come together and celebrate our differences. I'm still hopeful that things will get better and the centre will find its way back to being a beacon of excellence 💫.
 
I'm so sick of these arts orgs caving under Trump's ego 🙄. First off, net neutrality isn't the issue here - it's the fact that Grenell is more concerned with making Trump happy than actually funding arts programs. And now the Kennedy Center is basically a shadow of its former self? Give me a break! 👎 The fact that they're even considering relocating the opera company is a huge red flag for the future of arts in this country. Can't these orgs just stand up to politics and do what's best for art, not Trump's ego? 🤦‍♂️
 
idk why everyone's making a big deal about this kennedy center stuff 🤷‍♂️ i mean, it's just a theatre, right? they're still putting on shows and all that jazz. sure, some people might not like the new direction they're taking but can't we all just get along? 😊 and yeah, maybe some artists are getting a little too comfortable and need to be shaken up a bit. newsflash: art is subjective 🎨 it's not all about pleasing trump or whatever. i'm curious to see how this whole thing plays out tho 💁‍♂️
 
I'm so down for a good debate about art and politics 🤔... Problem is, this whole situation with the Kennedy Center has me all over the place. I mean, one minute it's like, 'Hey, let's fund art through ticket sales'... next thing you know, artists are leaving left and right because of Trump's influence 🎭. It's just too much drama for my taste.

On one hand, I get why they're trying to mix things up and bring in more fresh perspectives, but on the other hand, who gets left behind? The people who actually need funding to create art? And what about all those people who can't afford tickets or don't have the luxury of being able to shell out hundreds for a night at the opera 🤑? It's just not that simple.

I'm also kinda worried about what this means for the arts in general... if institutions start conforming to pressure, where does that leave us? As an artist myself, I value creative freedom way more than any amount of money or prestige 💸. But at the same time, I understand the need for stability and funding.

Ugh, this is just a mess 🤷‍♀️... what do you guys think should happen next?
 
OMG u dont even know wut u r missin @ Kennedy Center!!! 😱 Trump's influence is literally draining the soul outta that place 🕷️ it's like they're trying to suck the creativity outta every artist & musician 💔 ticket sales are thru the roof and ppl r deserting in droves 🚫 Francesca Zambello is right, its a funeral parlour over there 🎭😵 Gianandrea Noseda's statement was so ambiguous I'm still confused about wut he meant 🤔 NSO needs 2 do better than that 🎶 and the Smithsonian Portrait Gallery is all like "Trump who?" 🙄👀 anywayz, its super sad 4 the arts 🎭😢
 
idk what's going on with the Kennedy Center lol 🤯 it used to be all about arts and music, but now it's like a total hot mess 🚮 I mean, who needs ticket sales only? seems like they're just being super unfair to artists 🎨 and audiences alike. Francesca Zambello is totally right when she says the whole place feels like a funeral parlour 😔 where are all the talented people going? NSO's music director sounds pretty vague too... does anyone really know what he's talking about? 🤷‍♂️ the Smithsonian thing is kinda weird, but at least they're making a change. guess we'll just have to keep an eye on this whole cultural wars situation and see which side wins out 💪
 
I'm so done with this drama at the Kennedy Center 🤯! It's like they're trying to suck all the creativity out of it. First, Trump comes along and starts messing with everything, and now the opera company is on the verge of collapse? It's just sad. And what's up with the National Symphony Orchestra being left in limbo? I mean, I get that politics can be tricky, but can't they just stick to what they do best – making beautiful music? 🎵 The Smithsonian Institution swapping out Trump's portrait is just a weak attempt to appease him, if you ask me. It's like they're saying "Hey, we'll change the label on your picture, but don't expect us to challenge your views". Give me a break! 🙄
 
🤔 this whole thing is wild... i mean, the kennedy center was already facing some issues before trump got involved, but now it's like they're actively trying to drive artists and audiences away with their policies 🚫. net neutrality funding is a big part of it, but let's be real, that's just a fancy excuse for not wanting anyone else's money 💸. and it's not like the center was doing anything wrong before... they've always been about supporting local arts 🎭.

i don't think we should blame trump alone for this though, it's more like the kennedy center is feeling pressure to conform to some weird vision of what "american culture" should look like 🤷‍♀️. and that's something that should be debated in a public forum, not just in the halls of an institution like the kennedy center 💬.

anyway... i hope those who are fighting for artistic integrity keep pushing back against these kinds of demands 🙌. it's not always easy to speak out, but someone has to say something 👀.
 
I'm so done with the arts scene at the Kennedy Center 🤯. I mean, what happened to the good old days when you could attend a show and just enjoy the performance? Now it's all about politics and drama, like they're trying to suck the soul out of art itself 😔. The idea that ticket sales have plummeted is no surprise, but the fact that they're cutting off grants and philanthropic support is straight up cruel 🤑. I love classical music just as much as the next person, but can't we just keep it classy? 🎶.
 
I'm kinda torn about this whole Kennedy Center situation 🤔. On one hand, I get why artists and audiences are frustrated with the new policies - net neutrality is a big deal, and it's not cool that they're being forced to rely solely on ticket sales. That could really hurt the people who need arts funding the most 💸.

On the other hand, I do think Trump was trying to shake things up and make the centre more "American" in his own way 🇺🇸. But, like, at what cost? The fact that they're cancelling events and freaking out about it is pretty dramatic 😬. As for Gianandrea Noseda's comment... idk, man, I think he was just trying to be diplomatic and avoid saying anything too incendiary 🙏.

It's also weird how the Smithsonian Institution is getting into this fray over Trump's portrait. Like, can't they just leave it alone? 🤷‍♂️ And what does all this mean for the future of arts in America? Will we see more censorship and less diversity? Or will something more positive come out of all this? I guess only time will tell 🕰️.
 
🤔 this whole story is like a cautionary tale about the dangers of letting ideology cloud our judgement... once the Kennedy Center was a symbol of unity and artistic excellence, now it's like they're fighting an uphill battle to preserve what's truly important 🎨. richard grenell's 'net neutrality' policy might seem like a small thing on its own, but when you scale it up to the entire institution, it's like he's trying to suck all the life out of it 💀. and the fact that artists are leaving in droves is just a symptom of a deeper disease - a lack of understanding or empathy for the very things that bring people together 🎶. what does this say about us as a society? are we willing to sacrifice our collective soul for the sake of some fleeting idea of 'freedom'? 🤕
 
Back
Top