NYC's Congestion Pricing Scheme Spreads Benefits to Suburban Drivers
Researchers have found that New York City's congestion pricing scheme is having a positive impact on drivers beyond just pedestrians and cyclists. According to a new study, traffic backups in the outer boroughs and suburbs are decreasing, leading to shorter travel times for those outside of the city's congested zones.
The National Bureau of Economic Research conducted an analysis using Google Maps data, which revealed that traffic speeds have increased by up to 15% since congestion pricing was introduced. This translates to a saving of three minutes per journey for drivers who pay the $9 toll and navigate through the congested zone. The collective savings are staggering, with drivers shaving off a total of 83,000 hours from their weekly commutes.
Critics had worried that the scheme would simply shift traffic to surrounding areas, but instead, researchers found that trips on those streets have become shorter as well. Outside of Manhattan, traffic speeds increased by around 8%, with neighborhoods closer to the congestion zone experiencing even greater gains. Drivers who avoid the toll zone saved a collective 461,000 hours per week in traffic.
While some may argue that these benefits are limited, the study found that traffic speeds have improved across the tri-state area, including Long Island and highways. Notably, there was no evidence of offsetting slowdowns on different road types, suggesting that the policy has reduced overall traffic volumes rather than simply displacing congestion.
The findings come as a surprise to some who may have expected the scheme to be more divisive. President Trump had suggested that his administration would scrap the experiment, despite a lack of strong legal grounds for doing so. However, with evidence of its success mounting, one might hope that policymakers would take notice and continue to support this forward-thinking approach to reducing congestion in urban areas.
Researchers have found that New York City's congestion pricing scheme is having a positive impact on drivers beyond just pedestrians and cyclists. According to a new study, traffic backups in the outer boroughs and suburbs are decreasing, leading to shorter travel times for those outside of the city's congested zones.
The National Bureau of Economic Research conducted an analysis using Google Maps data, which revealed that traffic speeds have increased by up to 15% since congestion pricing was introduced. This translates to a saving of three minutes per journey for drivers who pay the $9 toll and navigate through the congested zone. The collective savings are staggering, with drivers shaving off a total of 83,000 hours from their weekly commutes.
Critics had worried that the scheme would simply shift traffic to surrounding areas, but instead, researchers found that trips on those streets have become shorter as well. Outside of Manhattan, traffic speeds increased by around 8%, with neighborhoods closer to the congestion zone experiencing even greater gains. Drivers who avoid the toll zone saved a collective 461,000 hours per week in traffic.
While some may argue that these benefits are limited, the study found that traffic speeds have improved across the tri-state area, including Long Island and highways. Notably, there was no evidence of offsetting slowdowns on different road types, suggesting that the policy has reduced overall traffic volumes rather than simply displacing congestion.
The findings come as a surprise to some who may have expected the scheme to be more divisive. President Trump had suggested that his administration would scrap the experiment, despite a lack of strong legal grounds for doing so. However, with evidence of its success mounting, one might hope that policymakers would take notice and continue to support this forward-thinking approach to reducing congestion in urban areas.
I mean 83k hours saved per week is insane! I was skeptical at first but it makes total sense that traffic speeds would increase outside of the city too, I drive to NY all the time and it's so much better now that they've implemented this. And can we talk about how this policy isn't just good for NYC but also for the rest of us who have to deal with congested roads everywhere? 
I'm so glad researchers are showing that it's actually reducing overall traffic volumes, not just displacing congestion. It's like a domino effect! 
. But apparently, paying that $9 toll has made all the difference for people outside of NYC. It's cool to see that the policy is actually reducing traffic volumes and speeding up travel times across the tri-state area 
.
It's clear that this scheme isn't just about city folk, but also those living outside of Manhattan.
. Now, let's hope policymakers take note and consider implementing similar schemes elsewhere! 
Interesting 
. It's gonna make suburban drivers even more salty about their daily commutes. I mean, who needs to save 3 whole minutes a day when you can just drive around the city and enjoy the views? And what's with all these "collective savings" - is it really that great for drivers outside of Manhattan? They're still gonna be stuck in traffic during rush hour. And don't even get me started on the tolls, $9 is like, a lot of cash 
. It'll just lead to more people avoiding public transportation and using their cars even more. Mark my words, this scheme will backfire 
.
Anyway, more of this please!
. And 83,000 hours shaved off from commutes? That's some serious time saved 
That would kinda negate the whole point of the congestion pricing scheme, right? 
President Trump wasn't exactly known for his nuanced understanding of urban planning 
.
Who knew paying a toll could make my daily commute so much better? 
Can't wait to see this policy expanded to other cities! 
. I mean, who wouldn't want to avoid getting stuck in traffic for three extra minutes a day? 
. Although, I'm not sure how much joy this news will bring to Trump and his crew... maybe they were just hoping for some good old-fashioned gridlock drama 
! I remember when the iPhone was still a shiny new thing (remember when it came out in 2007?) and we were just starting to get used to GPS navigation. Now, with all these ride-sharing services and electric cars on the road, it's like city planners are finally catching up with the times 
.
️
. And what about those who are making more money or have better job opportunities in the suburbs? Are they really benefiting from this scheme, or is it just another example of how the haves get even more convenient while the have-nots are stuck in traffic 
. Less traffic means less stress on the road, and more time for families to spend together or simply enjoy a quiet drive without the headache of traffic jams. And let's not forget about the time saved – 83k hours per week? That's like an extra day of sleep for our little ones 
. Have to give a shoutout to the researchers who made this study - their work is a great reminder that there are often creative solutions to our traffic woes 
!